The Short Answer
Shopify if you want to be selling this month, don't have technical help, and accept a monthly fee forever in exchange for everything just working.
WooCommerce if you want full control and lower running costs, and you have (or hire) someone technical to set it up and keep it maintained — because with WooCommerce, maintenance is your problem.
Neither if your "store" is really a service business with a handful of products or bookings — a lean custom build is often faster, cheaper to run, and easier to rank. More on that at the end.
What Each One Actually Is
Shopify is a rented store
A hosted subscription platform. Shopify runs the servers, security, and software. You configure your store in their dashboard and pay monthly for as long as you trade. Leave, and the store stays behind.
WooCommerce is a store you own
A free plugin that turns a WordPress site into a store. Nothing to pay the platform — but you supply the hosting, the setup, the security, and the updates, or pay someone who does.
The trade is convenience vs control
Shopify decides what you can customise and charges for the privilege of not worrying. WooCommerce lets you change anything and makes everything your responsibility. Neither trade-off is wrong — they suit different owners.
What They Cost in Rands
Shopify bills in US dollars, so your platform fee moves with the exchange rate — worth remembering when the rand has a bad quarter.
Figures are typical ranges at time of writing — confirm current pricing before committing. Full breakdown in our e-commerce cost guide.
The South African Specifics
Payment gateways: both are fine
PayFast, Peach Payments, and Yoco all integrate with both platforms. This used to be Shopify's weakness in SA; it isn't anymore. Pick your gateway on fees, not platform.
Shipping: check your courier first
SA courier integration (The Courier Guy, Fastway, Aramex — usually via Bob Go or uAfrica) is solid on both, but plugin/app quality varies. If you ship physical goods daily, test the shipping flow before you commit to anything.
Load shedding & hosting reality
Shopify's hosting is global and bulletproof. WooCommerce is only as reliable as the hosting you pay for — cheap shared hosting is where WooCommerce reputations go to die. Budget for decent hosting or don't choose Woo.
Speed and SEO
A well-built store ranks on either platform. But an unmaintained WooCommerce site loaded with plugins gets slow, and slow loses both rankings and checkouts. Shopify is harder to break; Woo is easier to perfect — and easier to ruin.
Decide in 60 Seconds
Choose Shopify if…
- You're non-technical with no developer on call
- You need to launch fast and iterate
- Predictable monthly cost beats ownership for you
- Your margins comfortably absorb the fees
Choose WooCommerce if…
- You want to own the store outright
- You need custom functionality Shopify restricts
- You already run WordPress and know its upkeep
- Lower running costs justify higher setup cost
The Third Option Nobody Mentions
If you sell a small, stable catalogue — 5 to 50 products, or services with deposits — you may not need a platform at all. A lean custom store with PayFast or Yoco checkout loads faster than either platform, has no monthly platform fee, no plugin updates, and nothing to hack.
Platforms earn their keep at scale: hundreds of products, stock sync, complex shipping rules. Below that scale, they're often overhead you're renting out of habit.
Not Sure Which Fits Your Store?
Tell us what you sell and how you work. We'll recommend the right approach honestly — including when that's Shopify and not us.
Get Honest Advice